Covid-19 Research

Research Article

OCLC Number/Unique Identifier: 9342082659

Recent Developments in Purification Techniques for Whey Valorization

Medicine Group    Start Submission

Maham Aslam, Ansa Khalid, Ghanwa Tahir and Hamid Mukhtar*

Volume2-Issue9
Dates: Received: 2021-06-13 | Accepted: 2021-07-30 | Published: 2021-09-30
Pages: 876-887

Abstract

Whey being a by-product of dairy industry, although is highly nutritive, was previously regarded as a waste but with time found its application in feedstock, pharmaceutical and food industry. Whey’s composition varies with respect to multiple factors such as source of milk, type of whey (acid or sweet whey) etc. Main challenge in whey utilization is that it has less quantity of whey constituents which need to be purified. Previously, the methods such as heat or acid treatment, precipitation and salting out were efficient only on laboratory scale and caused degradation of native protein structure making it difficult to understand its functional, nutritional and therapeutic properties, shifting focus towards innovative techniques which give product of high purity, are rapid, efficient, cost effective, eco-friendly and easy to be scaled up. Among such techniques, membrane separation and chromatography are widely employed ones. There is always a concern about purity and use of a single technique leads to compromise between purification level and overall purified product yield, shifting focus towards coupling of separation techniques. The following article is a comprehensive approach towards novel approaches for the isolation and separation of different whey constituents such as whey protein isolate and whey protein hydrolysate etc. along with their application in dairy, food and pharmaceutical industry and animal feedstock.

FullText HTML FullText PDF DOI: 10.37871/jbres1326


Certificate of Publication




Copyright

© 2021 Aslam M, et al. Distributed under Creative Commons CC-BY 4.0

How to cite this article

Aslam M, Khalid A, Tahir G, Mukhtar H. Recent Developments in Purification Techniques for Whey Valorization. J Biomed Res Environ Sci. 2021 Sept 30; 2(9): 876-887. doi: 10.37871/jbres1326, Article ID: JBRES1326, Available at: https://www.jelsciences.com/articles/jbres1326.pdf


Subject area(s)

References


  1. Smithers GW. Whey and whey proteins - From “gutter-to-gold.” International Dairy Journal. 2008;18(7):695–704. https://tinyurl.com/xuxbk5dz
  2. El-Sayed MM, Chase HA. Trends in whey protein fractionation. Biotechnol Lett. 2011 Aug;33(8):1501-11. doi: 10.1007/s10529-011-0594-8. Epub 2011 Mar 19. PMID: 21424166.
  3. Argenta AB, Scheer. Membrane Separation Processes Applied to Whey: A Review. Food Reviews International. 2019. https://tinyurl.com/juh7kpuj
  4. Kaur N, Sharma S, Jaimni Kehinde Kaur. Recent developments in purification techniques and industrial applications for whey valorization: A review. Chemical Engineering Communications. 2019. https://tinyurl.com/xjbmzuww
  5. Chavan RS, Shraddha, Kumar, Nalawade. Whey based beverage: Its functionality, formulations, health benefits and applications. Journal of Food Processing and Technology. 2015;6:1-2. https://tinyurl.com/62m6b4cj
  6. Valino V, Roman R, Ibanez, Ortiz. Improved separation of bovine serum albumin and lactoferrin mixtures using charged ultrafiltration membranes. Separation and Purification Technology. 2014;25:163–169. https://tinyurl.com/3bccupcv
  7. Aguero RE, Bringas MF, San Roman, I Ortiz, R Ibanez. Membrane processes for whey proteins separation and purification. A Review. Current Organic Chemistry. 2017;21:1740-1752. https://tinyurl.com/trpvphh7
  8. Ramos OL, Pereira, Rodrigues, Teixeira, Vicente, Malcata. Whey and Whey Powders: Production and Uses. Encyclopedia of Food and Health. 2016;498-505. https://tinyurl.com/2yts32su
  9. Tsakali E, Petrotos, Allessandro, Goulas. A review on whey composition and the methods used for its utilization for food and pharmaceutical products. 6th International conference on simulation and modelling in the food and bio-industry. 2010. https://tinyurl.com/9ypnnwce
  10. Baldasso C, Lazzari, Scopel, Marczak and Tessaro. Concentration and purification of whey proteins by ultrafiltration. Desalination. 2011;278:381-386. https://tinyurl.com/4nfamuww
  11. Lievore P, Simoes KM, Silva NL, Drunkler AC. Chemical characterisation and application of acid whey in fermented milk. Journal of Food Science and Technology. 2013. doi: 10.1007/s13197-013-1244-z.
  12. Liu Y, Zhao X, Liu M, Zhao J. Cheese Manufacturing and Bioactive Substance Separation: Separation and Preliminary Purification of cAMP from Whey. Korean J Food Sci Anim Resour. 2018 Feb;38(1):52-63. doi: 10.5851/kosfa.2018.38.1.052. Epub 2018 Feb 28. PMID: 29725224; PMCID: PMC5932959.
  13. Pate SA, Parikh. Production of lactic acid from whey by Lactobacillus sp. isolated from local dairy products. International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences. 2016;5:734-741. https://tinyurl.com/5pe5xhcs
  14. Schuck P. Spray drying of dairy products: state of the art. 2002:375-382. doi: 10.1051/lait:2002017. https://tinyurl.com/36h3zheh
  15. Doultani S, Turhan, Etzel. Fractionation of proteins from whey using cation exchange chromatography. Process Biochemistry. 2004;39:1737-1743. https://tinyurl.com/m4mxtrvj
  16. Plate K, Beutel S, Buchholz H, Demmer W, Fischer-Frühholz S, Reif O, Ulber R, Scheper T. Isolation of bovine lactoferrin, lactoperoxidase and enzymatically prepared lactoferricin from proteolytic digestion of bovine lactoferrin using adsorptive membrane chromatography. J Chromatogr A. 2006 Jun 2;1117(1):81-6. doi: 10.1016/j.chroma.2006.03.090. Epub 2006 Apr 17. PMID: 16616760.
  17. Teepakorn C. Optimization of lactoferrin and bovine serum albumin separation using ion-exchange membrane chromatography. Separation and Purification Technology. 2015;151:292-302. https://tinyurl.com/b4a8t6bd
  18. Qiong W, Chao, Fenga, Xia, Lin. Whey protein membrane processing methods and membrane fouling mechanism analysis. Food Chemistry. 2019;289:468-481. https://tinyurl.com/6zp9tsfy
  19. Saxena A, Tripathi BP, Kumar M, Shahi VK. Membrane-based techniques for the separation and purification of proteins: an overview. Adv Colloid Interface Sci. 2009 Jan 30;145(1-2):1-22. doi: 10.1016/j.cis.2008.07.004. Epub 2008 Aug 5. PMID: 18774120.
  20. Baldasso C, Lazzari, Scopel, Marczak and Tessaro. Whey fractionation through membranes separation process. Separation Science and Technology. 2016. https://tinyurl.com/2ckvzres
  21. Riera F, González P, Muro C. Whey cheese: membrane technology to increase yields. J Dairy Res. 2016 Feb;83(1):96-103. doi: 10.1017/S0022029915000679. PMID: 26869115
  22. Barukcic I, Bozanic, Kulozik. Influence of process temperature and microfiltration pre-treatment on flux and fouling intensity during cross-flow ultrafiltration of sweet whey using ceramic membranes. International Dairy Journal. 2016;51:1-7. https://tinyurl.com/444ytpb5
  23. Sprinchan EG. Optimization of technological regimes for obtaining protein-mineral concentrated products from secondary milk raw materials. Surface Engineering and Applied Electrochemistry. 2009;45:63-70. https://tinyurl.com/tdmucrde
  24. Qiong, Wei, Xue, Yi. Cheese whey protein recovery by ultrafiltration through Transglutaminase (TG) catalysis whey protein cross-linking, Food Chemistry. 2017;215:31-40. https://tinyurl.com/4bszj9tc
  25. Muller AG, Daufin, Chaufer. Ultrafiltration modes of operation for separation of a-lactalbumin from acid casein whey. Journal of Membrane Science. 1999;153:9-21. https://tinyurl.com/28y8y9ay
  26. Almecija MCR, Ibanez A, Guadix EM, Guadix. Effect of pH on the fractionation of whey proteins with a ceramic ultrafiltration membrane. Journal of Membrane Science. 2007;288:28-35. https://tinyurl.com/szpvh5dh
  27. Slukova M, Hinkova, Henke, Smrz, Lukacikova, Pour, Bubnık Z. Cheese whey treated by membrane separation as a valuable ingredient for barley sourdough preparation. Journal of Food Engineering. 2016;172:38–47. https://tinyurl.com/42pcmukb
  28. Holzmuller, Kulozik. Isolation of Milk Fat Globule Membrane (MFGM) material by coagulation and diafiltration of buttermilk. International Dairy Journal. 2016;63:88-91. https://tinyurl.com/ft2tvsrp
  29. Datta D, Bhattacharjee, Datta S. Whey protein fractionation using membrane filtration: A review. Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers. 2008;89:45-50. https://tinyurl.com/22zvrv29
  30. Arunkumar A, Etzel. Fractionation of a-lactalbumin and b-lactoglobulin from bovine milk serum using staged, positively charged, tangential flow ultrafiltration membranes. Journal of Membrane Science. 2014;454:488-495. https://tinyurl.com/4hjcrvv3
  31. Cheang B, Zydney. A two-stage ultrafiltration process for fractionation of whey protein isolate. Journal of Membrane Science. 2004;231:159-167. https://tinyurl.com/5r242ha8
  32. Chen G, Song B, Qi J, Ghosh, Wan. Separation of protein mixtures by an integrated electro-ultrafiltration-electrodialysis process. Separation and Purification Technology. 2015;147:32-43. https://tinyurl.com/awwye9fv
  33. Enevoldsen AD, Hansen, Jonsson. Electro-ultrafiltration of industrial enzyme solution. Journal of Membrane Science. 2007;299(1-2):28-37. https://tinyurl.com/ysu5j6ft
  34. Valino V, Roman R, Ibanez, Benito, Escudero. Accurate determination of key surface properties that determine the efficient separation of bovine milk BSA and LF proteins. Separation and Purification Technology. 2014;135:145-157. https://tinyurl.com/3rdxy6k5
  35. Galier S, Balmann. The electrophoretic membrane contactor: A mass-transfer-based methodology applied to the separation of whey proteins. Separation and Purification Technology. 2011;77:237-244. https://tinyurl.com/5b4fr37h
  36. Ndiaye N, Pouliot L, Saucier L, Beaulieu, Bazinet. Electroseparation of bovine lactoferrin from model and whey solutions. Separation and Purification Technology. 2010;74:93-99. https://tinyurl.com/y9km7wk8
  37. Priyadarshini R, Gerard, Deepak. Chromatography - the essence of bioanalysis, European Journal of Biomedical and Pharmaceutical Sciences. 2016;3:366-377. https://tinyurl.com/n7j595x3
  38. Wilchek M, Chaiken. An overview of affinity chromatography in affinity chromatography–Methods and protocols. Humana Press. 2000;1-6.
  39. Firer MA. Efficient elution of functional proteins in affinity chromatography. J Biochem Biophys Methods. 2001 Oct 30;49(1-3):433-42. doi: 10.1016/s0165-022x(01)00211-1. PMID: 11694292.
  40. Urtasun N, Baieli, Hirsch, Martinez, Cascone, Wolman. Lactoperoxidase purification from whey by using dye affinity chromatography. Food and Bioproducts Processing. 2017;103:58–65. https://tinyurl.com/mayrvd7r
  41. Besselink T, Janssen, Boom. Isolation of bovine serum albumin from whey using affinity chromatography. International Dairy Journal. 2015;41:32-37. https://tinyurl.com/28dxmhx2
  42. Puerta A, Jaulmes A, De Frutos M, Diez-Masa JC, Vidal-Madjar C. Adsorption kinetics of beta-lactoglobulin on a polyclonal immunochromatographic support. J Chromatogr A. 2002 Apr 12;953(1-2):17-30. doi: 10.1016/s0021-9673(02)00124-3. PMID: 12058931.
  43. Wolman FJDG, Maglio, Grasselli Cascone. One-step lactoferrin purification from bovine whey and colostrum by affinity membrane chromatography. Journal of Membrane Science. 2007;288:132–138. https://tinyurl.com/kvf4e4a8
  44. Ounis WB, Gauthierm, Turgeon, Roufik, Pouliot Y. Separation of minor protein components from whey protein isolates by heparin affinity chromatography. International Dairy Journal. 2008;18:1043-1050. https://tinyurl.com/h2t8d66b
  45. Baieli MFN, Urtasun MV, Miranda O, Cascone, Wolman. Isolation of lactoferrin from whey by dye-affinity chromatography with yellow HE-4R attached to chitosan mini-spheres. International Dairy Journal. 2014;39:53-59. https://tinyurl.com/43asa483
  46. Fekete S, Beck A, Veuthey JL, Guillarme D. Ion-exchange chromatography for the characterization of biopharmaceuticals. J Pharm Biomed Anal. 2015 Sep 10;113:43-55. doi: 10.1016/j.jpba.2015.02.037. Epub 2015 Feb 26. PMID: 25800161.
  47. Jungbauer A, Hahn. Ion-exchange chromatography. Methods Enzymology. 2009;463:349-371.
  48. Lenhoff AM. Ion-exchange chromatography of proteins: the inside story, Mater. Today: Proceedings. 2016;3(10):3559-3567. https://tinyurl.com/rb6u7r3e
  49. Nakano T, Ozimek L, Betti M. Separation of bovine κ-casein glycomacropeptide from sweet whey protein products with undetectable level of phenylalanine by protein precipitation followed by anion exchange chromatography. J Dairy Res. 2018 Feb;85(1):110-113. doi: 10.1017/S0022029917000838. PMID: 29468990.
  50. Goodall S, Grandison AS, Jauregi PJ, Price J. Selective separation of the major whey proteins using ion exchange membranes. J Dairy Sci. 2008 Jan;91(1):1-10. doi: 10.3168/jds.2007-0539. PMID: 18096919.
  51. Santos MJ, Teixeira, Rodrigues. Fractionation of the major whey proteins and isolation of b-Lactoglobulin variants by anion exchange chromatography. Separation and Purification Technology. 2012;90:133-139. https://tinyurl.com/e7fznpaw
  52. Dong S, Chen L, Dai B, Johnson W, Ye J, Shen S, Yun J, Yao K, Lin DQ, Yao SJ. Isolation of immunoglobulin G from bovine milk whey by poly (hydroxyethyl methacrylate)-based anion-exchange cryogel. J Sep Sci. 2013 Aug;36(15):2387-93. doi: 10.1002/jssc.201300306. Epub 2013 Jul 8. PMID: 23720373.
  53. El-Sayed MM, Chase HA. Simulation of the breakthrough curves for the adsorption of a-lactalbumin and b-lactoglobulin to SP sepharose FF cation-exchanger. Biochemical Engineering Journal. 2010;49:221–228. https://tinyurl.com/aymcd2xy
  54. Du QY, Lin, Xiong Yao SJ. One-step purification of lactoferrin from crude sweet whey using cation-exchange expanded bed adsorption. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research. 2013;52:2693-2699. https://tinyurl.com/y587awa3
  55. Pan M, Shen, Chen, Dai, Xu, Yun, Yao, Lin, Yao. Separation of lactoperoxidase from bovine whey milk by cation exchange composite cryogel embedded macroporous cellulose beads. Separation and Purification Technology. 2015;147:132-138. https://tinyurl.com/2f77tpzw
  56. Voswinkel L, Kulozik. Fractionation of all major and minor whey proteins with radial flow membrane adsorption chromatography at lab and pilot scale. International Dairy Journal. 2014;39:209-214. https://tinyurl.com/3bc3cu63
  57. Xu Y, R Sleigh, J Hourigan, R Johnson. Separation of bovine immunoglobulin G and glycomacropeptide from dairy whey. Process Biochemestry. 2000;36(5):393-399. https://tinyurl.com/99y6n6rr
  58. Bhattacharjee S, Bhattacharjee, Datta. Studies on the fractionation of beta-lactoglobulin from casein whey using ultrafiltration and ion exchange membrane chromatography. Journal of Membrane Science. 2015;275:141-150. https://tinyurl.com/79yumsuw
  59. Konrad G, Kleinschmidt. A new method for isolation of native alpha-lactalbumin from sweet whey. International Dairy Journal. 2008;18:47-54. https://tinyurl.com/5ykackjx
  60. Konrad G, Lieske, Faber. A large-scale isolation of native beta-lactoglobulin: characterization of physicochemical properties and comparison with other methods. International Dairy Journal. 2000;10:713-721. https://tinyurl.com/52kzfsf6
  61. Heebøll-Nielsen A, Justesen SF, Thomas OR. Fractionation of whey proteins with high-capacity superparamagnetic ion-exchangers. J Biotechnol. 2004 Sep 30;113(1-3):247-62. doi: 10.1016/j.jbiotec.2004.06.008. PMID: 15380659.
  62. Chen L, Guo, Guan, Liu. Isolation of lactoferrin from acid whey by magnetic affinity separation. Separation and Purification Technology. 2007;56:168–174. https://tinyurl.com/ajk9es8w
  63. Coimbra JD, Thömmes, Kula. Continuous separation of whey proteins with aqueous two-phase systems in a Graesser contactor. Journal of Chromatography A. 1994;668(1):85–94. https://tinyurl.com/54564cmt
  64. El-Sayed MM, Chase HA. Purification of the two major proteins from whey concentrate using a cation-exchange selective adsorption process. Biotechnol Prog. 2010 Jan-Feb;26(1):192-9. doi: 10.1002/btpr.316. PMID: 19927316.
  65. Bazinet L, Ippersiel D, Mahdavi B. Effect of conductivity control on the separation of whey proteins by bipolar membrane electroacidification. J Agric Food Chem. 2004 Apr 7;52(7):1980-4. doi: 10.1021/jf0348469. PMID: 15053539.
  66. Ganju S, Gogate. A review on approaches for efficient recovery of whey proteins from dairy industry effluents. Journal of Food Engineering. 2017;215:84-96. https://tinyurl.com/4hd99fu9
  67. Sandrou DK, Arvanitoyannis IS. Low-fat/calorie foods: current state and perspectives. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2000 Sep;40(5):427-47. doi: 10.1080/10408690091189211. PMID: 11029012.
  68. Sołowiej B. Textural, rheological and melting properties of acid casein reduced-fat processed cheese analogues. Milchwissenschaft Journal. 2012;67:9–13. https://tinyurl.com/ebzckfky
  69. Johnson BR. Whey protein concentrates in low-fat applications. U.S. Dairy export council, applications monograph. Low-fat applications. 2000;1-8. https://tinyurl.com/8dwescrn
  70. Madureira AR, Pereira AMP, Gomes ME. Pintado, Malcata FX. Bovine whey proteins - Overview on their main biological properties. International Food Research Journal. 2007;40(10):1197-1211. https://tinyurl.com/52z5peww
  71. Zhang T, McCarthy J, Wang G, Liu Y, Guo M. Physiochemical properties, microstructure, and probiotic survivability of nonfat goats’ milk yogurt using heat-treated whey protein concentrate as fat replacer. J Food Sci. 2015 Apr;80(4):M788-94. doi: 10.1111/1750-3841.12834. Epub 2015 Mar 21. PMID: 25808084.
  72. Gallardo-Escamilla FJ, Kelly AL, Delahunty CM. Sensory characteristics and related volatile flavor compound profiles of different types of whey. J Dairy Sci. 2005 Aug;88(8):2689-99. doi: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(05)72947-7. PMID: 16027181.
  73. Liu K, Y Tian, M Stieger, E Van der, Velde. Evidence for ball-bearing mechanism of microparticulated whey protein as fat replacer in liquid and semi-solid multi-component. Food Hydrocolloids. 2016;52:403-414. https://tinyurl.com/upn5vyep
  74. Sodini I, Montella, Tong. Physical properties of yogurt fortified with various commercial whey protein concentrates. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture. 2005;85(5):853-859. https://tinyurl.com/369y4xyy
  75. Lim SY, Swanson BG, Ross CF, Clark S. High hydrostatic pressure modification of whey protein concentrate for improved body and texture of lowfat ice cream. J Dairy Sci. 2008 Apr;91(4):1308-16. doi: 10.3168/jds.2007-0391. PMID: 18349223.
  76. Alfaifi MS, Stathopoulos. Effect of egg yolk substitution by sweet Whey Protein Concentrate (WPC), on physical properties of Gelato ice cream. International Food Research Journal. 2009;17:787-793. https://tinyurl.com/653xkp8u
  77. Philippopoulos CD, Papadakis. Current trends in whey processing and utilization in Greece. International Journal of Dairy Technology. 2001;54:14-19. https://tinyurl.com/y9f5c7nz
  78. Sołowiej B, Cheung, Chan. Texture, rheology and meltability of processed cheese analogues prepared using rennet or acid casein with or without added whey proteins. International Dairy Journal. 2014;37:87–94. https://tinyurl.com/w7dckkm2
  79. Sattin E, Andreani NA, Carraro L, Lucchini R, Fasolato L, Telatin A, Balzan S, Novelli E, Simionati B, Cardazzo B. A Multi-Omics Approach to Evaluate the Quality of Milk Whey Used in Ricotta Cheese Production. Front Microbiol. 2016 Aug 17;7:1272. doi: 10.3389/fmicb.2016.01272. PMID: 27582735; PMCID: PMC4987355.
  80. Durham RJ, Sleigh, Hourigan. Pharmaceutical lactose: a new whey with no waste. Australian Journal of Dairy Technology. 2004;59(2):138-141. https://tinyurl.com/5mvvbc8p
  81. Gunasekaran S, L Xiao. Use of whey proteins for encapsulation and controlled delivery applications. Journal of Food Engineering. 2007;83(1):31-40. https://tinyurl.com/44a8xbc5
  82. Bayizit A, T Ozcan, LY Ersan. Membrane processes in production of functional whey components. Mljekarstvo. 2010;4:282-288. https://tinyurl.com/y26r4euy
  83. Baieli MF, Urtasun N, Martinez MJ, Hirsch DB, Pilosof AM, Miranda MV, Cascone O, Wolman FJ. Affinity chromatography matrices for depletion and purification of casein glycomacropeptide from bovine whey. Biotechnol Prog. 2017 Jan;33(1):171-180. doi: 10.1002/btpr.2404. Epub 2016 Nov 29. PMID: 27897433.
  84. Aboumahmoud R, Savello P. Crosslinking of whey protein by transglutaminase. J Dairy Sci. 1990 Feb;73(2):256-63. doi: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(90)78668-7. PMID: 1970346.
  85. Jara F, Pilosof. Partitioning of alpha-lactalbumin and beta-lactoglobulin in whey protein concentrate/ hydroxypropyl methyl cellulose aqueous two-phase systems. Food Hydrocolloids. 2011;25(3):374-380. https://tinyurl.com/54u8sf8v
  86. Królczyk J, Dawidziuk E, Turak, Sołowiej. 2016. Use of whey and whey preparations in the food industry - a review. Polish Journal of Food and Nutrition Sciences. 2016;66(3):157-165. doi:10.1515/pjfns-2015-0052.
  87. Patel S. Emerging trends in nutraceutical applications of whey protein and its derivatives. J Food Sci Technol. 2015 Nov;52(11):6847-58. doi: 10.1007/s13197-015-1894-0. Epub 2015 Jun 9. PMID: 26884639; PMCID: PMC4744604.
  88. Salvatore E, Pes M, Falchi G, Pagnozzi D, Furesi S, Fiori M, Roggio T, Addis MF, Pirisi A. Effect of whey concentration on protein recovery in fresh ovine ricotta cheese. J Dairy Sci. 2014;97(8):4686-94. doi: 10.3168/jds.2013-7762. Epub 2014 May 23. PMID: 24856986.
  89. Sinha R, Radha, Prakash, Kaul. Whey protein hydrolysate: Functional properties, nutritional quality and utilization in beverage formulation. Food Chemistry. 2007;101:1484-1491.
  90. Steinhauer T, Schwing, Kraub, Kulozik. Enhancement of ultrafiltration-performance and improvement of hygienic quality during the production of whey concentrates. International Dairy Journal. 2015;45:8-14. https://tinyurl.com/ytvfu6j7


Comments


Swift, Reliable, and studious. We aim to cherish the world by publishing precise knowledge.

  • asd
  • Brown University Library
  • University of Glasgow Library
  • University of Pennsylvania, Penn Library
  • University of Amsterdam Library
  • The University of British Columbia Library
  • UC Berkeley’s Library
  • MIT Libraries
  • Kings College London University
  • University of Texas Libraries
  • UNSW Sidney Library
  • The University of Hong Kong Libraries
  • UC Santa Barbara Library
  • University of Toronto Libraries
  • University of Oxford Library
  • Australian National University
  • ScienceOpen
  • UIC Library
  • KAUST University Library
  • Cardiff University Library
  • Ball State University Library
  • Duke University Library
  • Rutgers University Library
  • Air University Library
  • UNT University of North Texas
  • Washington Research Library Consortium
  • Penn State University Library
  • Georgetown Library
  • Princeton University Library
  • Science Gate
  • Internet Archive
  • WashingTon State University Library
  • Dimensions
  • Zenodo
  • OpenAire
  • Index Copernicus International
  • icmje
  •  International Scientific Indexing (ISI)
  • Sherpa Romeo
  • ResearchGate
  • Universidad De Lima
  • WorldCat
  • JCU Discovery
  • McGill
  • National University of Singepore Libraries
  • SearchIT
  • Scilit
  • SemantiScholar
  • Base Search
  • VU
  • KB
  • Publons
  • oaji
  • Harvard University
  • sjsu-library
  • UWLSearch
  • Florida Institute of Technology
  • CrossRef
  • LUBsearch
  • Universitat de Paris
  • Technical University of Denmark
  • ResearchBIB
  • Google Scholar
  • Microsoft Academic Search