Over 350 million cats worldwide live in homes with their human companions. An inexplicable phenomenon is affecting domestic cats (felis catus) - the global prevalence of feline hyperthyroidism has been increasing since the late 1970s. Feline hyperthyroidism is the result of a malignant thyroid carcinoma in ~2% and a benign functional thyroid adenoma in ~98% of diagnosed cases. Thyroid tumors remain palpable in cats after medication (e.g., methimazole, carbimazole), but few studies have reported such remaining tumors. Hence, we pathologically examined tissues that were sampled from 206 cats by thyroidectomy after such medication at 65 veterinary hospitals. Our results show carcinoma in 11.2% and adenoma in 83.4% of samples. Based on an increase in the carcinoma rate from ~2% at the diagnosis stage to 11.2% at the post-treatment stage, it can be inferred that a thyroid adenoma transforms into a thyroid carcinoma in a hyperthyroid cat through a multistep mutational pathway like the human adenoma-carcinoma sequence. It remains for future study to assess whether this feline phenomenon is somehow related to the human one in terms of the One Health approach; e.g., the incidence rate of thyroid cancers has been increasing in humans since the early 1980s (cf. this tendency cannot be explained only by over-diagnosis and detection technology).
There is little in history to show any large numbers of animals having been kept as pets. Although the reasons that pet keeping has become a widespread cultural phenomenon are unclear, it is evident from the prevalence of the practice that companion animals are vitally important in human lives [1]. In Japan, the number of pet animals (~18.1 million) now significantly exceeds the number of children (~15.1 million under 15 years old), so how to live a comfortable life with pets is a major issue for consideration as a country with a shrinking birth rate and rising number of elderly citizens [2]. As people have come to treat pet animals like family members, their concern about their pet’s health/well-being has also grown over recent years (cf. 92% of pet owners in the US are as concerned about their pet’s health as their own health [3]). Pet healthcare is now a high priority for both owners and veterinary practices. Consequently, animal hospitals specializing in pets are increasing in number, and many owners have their pets on waitlists for medical treatment [4].
Looking at it from a different perspective, pets and wild animals have been used to predict adverse effects on the human population. In a modern example, canaries were used to detect the toxic gas sarin (isopropyl methylphosphonofluoridate) after it was released into the Tokyo subways by a terrorist cult in 1995 [5]. Animals suffer a similar spectrum of disease as humans, and they are sensitive indicators and provide an early warning signal for human health intervention [6]. The One Health approach indicates that human, animal and environment are closely interconnected, and this approach has gained worldwide attention in recent years.
The annually increasing incidence of malignant tumors is of great concern in medical treatment for pet animals [7,8], and pet-owning communities demonstrate an increasing expectation for advanced veterinary oncology services [9]. In addition, it is also necessary to consider current disease trends among animals and humans from the One Health viewpoint. Against this backdrop, we focus on a common disease in domestic cats to reconsider whether the well-known therapy for this disease is truly effective and to contemplate whether the pathogenetic mechanisms are somehow related to malignancy risk in pet animals and humans. Basic information is briefly reviewed first.
It is estimated that over 350 million cats worldwide live in homes with their human companions [10]. In domestic cats (felis catus), the prevalence of hyperthyroidism has been constantly increasing worldwide since veterinary evidence for this feline disorder was first reported in 1979 [11,12], and it is now recognized worldwide as the most common feline endocrine disorder. Annual incidence rates indicate that ~10% of cats older than 9 years in the US [11], ~12% of cats older than 9 years in the UK [11], ~9% of cats older than 9 years in Japan [11], ~8% of cats older than 10 years in Spain [13] and ~11% of cats older than 8 years in Germany [14] suffer from hyperthyroidism.
According to a review report on safety and efficacy assessments of anti-thyroid drugs such as methimazole and carbimazole [16], most of the medical treatments for feline hyperthyroidism have been borrowed from efficient treatments for human thyroid disease. Thyroid tumors remain palpable in cats after medication for controlling thyroid hormone concentrations [16,20]. A palpable thyroid abnormality suggests a possible presence of (i) thyroid dysfunction, (ii) obstruction or (iii) malignancy in humans, so it is recommended to conduct further tests for confirmation [21]. However, few studies have been reported on such remaining palpable tumors in cats. We therefore utilized thyroidectomy (a curative therapy option) to effectively sample thyroid tissues from hyperthyroid cats in collaboration with veterinary hospitals for the purpose of conducting a large-scale pathological observation of post-treatment tumors.
Typical treatments for feline hyperthyroidism are briefly reviewed as follows [11,12,15]. Medication (e.g., methimazole, thiamazole or carbimazole) is often the first line of therapy because the advantages of medication are that the drugs are readily available, simple and relatively inexpensive [11,12,15]. Although the medication using anti-thyroid drugs regulates thyroid hormone production [11,12,15], it cannot decrease the tumor size to cure the disease [16,22]. Furthermore, there is a possibility that some cats may experience side effects such as vomiting, anorexia, fever, anemia and lethargy [15].
It has been reported that hyperthyroid cats treated with long-term medication do not have a total Thyroxine (T4) level significantly different from untreated cats (reviewed in [23]). In the case that the demerits surpass the merits and/or a lack of efficacy continues in medical therapy over a prolonged period, curative treatments may be practical. They include (i) destruction of abnormal thyroid tissues through injection of radioactive iodine (iodine-131), and (ii) surgical removal of hyperthyroid glands [15]. The former has no serious side effects and avoids anaesthesia. This therapy provides a cure in ~95% of cases [15], but the handling/injection of a radioactive substance is not available to all practitioners [15]; e.g., there are 13 radioactive iodine facilities for veterinary services in the UK, in contrast, such facilities have not been legally licensed in Japan [24]. The latter is less common and is called thyroidectomy. It makes it possible to surgically resect hyper functioning thyroid glands [11,12,15]. From the viewpoint of our research approach, thyroidectomy is the only effective way of collecting a large number of tissue samples from hyperthyroid cats during their therapy.
Each thyroid tissue was sampled from a diagnosed cat by thyroidectomy as a curative treatment, and the tissue sample was fixed with 10% neutral-buffered formalin immediately after resection. The fixed sample was put in an airtight plastic container and sent to a pathology laboratory. After that, sections of the mass and grossly normal small intestines in close proximity to the mass were prepared. The tissues were stained with hematoxylin and eosin to examine a tissue portion under a microscope to see the structure and appearance of cells.
As stated above, radioactive iodine therapy is an effective and curative option for hyperthyroid cats. With the spread of radiation therapy, thyroidectomy will become much less common at local practices. If that is the case, large-scale sampling of thyroid tissues from thyroidectomy will inevitably become inaccessible in the near future. Before this happens, we carried out a sampling of thyroid tissues in cooperation with 65 animal hospitals located in the Hokkaido, Tohoku, Kanto, Tokai, Kansai, Chugoku and Kyushu regions of Japan during a 6-year period from 2019 to 2024, and we pathologically examined the tissues that were sampled from 206 cats by thyroidectomy after a certain period of medical therapy.
It is generally known that adenoma is a benign tumor (i.e., non-cancerous) arising from glandular tissue and carcinoma with metastasis ability is a malignant tumor derived from epithelial cells. Previous studies have reported that feline hyperthyroidism is the result of a malignant thyroid carcinoma (adenocarcinoma) in ~2% of diagnosed cases and a benign functional adenoma is responsible in ~98% of diagnosed cases [11,12]. By contrast, the results summarized in figure 2 show a comparatively high rate (~11%) of thyroid carcinoma and a comparatively low rate (~83%) of thyroid adenoma in the examined samples.
A cat with ID number BP20-1438 is characterized as a mixed breed, sterilized female of 15 years of age at the time. When she had a health check including a T4 blood test in October 2019, she was diagnosed with hyperthyroidism on the basis of 13.2 μg/dL T4 value (cf. reference range of 0.9‒3.7μg/dL). As treatment, 2.5 mg/day of mercazole (brand name methimazole) was administered to her every day, and she was not interested in any veterinary diets containing low levels of iodine; in consequence, the T4 value decreased only to 6.4μg/dL in November. The drug dose was increased to 4.0 mg/day, and the T4 value dropped to 2.7μg/dL in December; however, she had serious side effects during her medical therapy, in particular intense itchiness. She often scratched her face and ears because of her itchiness, and they were torn and bled. Finally, she had a thyroidectomy in January 2020. The thyroid tissues sampled from her thyroidectomy are shown in figure 3 - there were follicular-patterned lesions (Figure 3A) in multi-nodular form (Figure 3B) in the thyroid glands, and these lesions were well-circumscribed (Figure 3C) and comparatively inhomogeneous. Furthermore, they did not infiltrate through the surrounding normal tissues, so this cat was pathologically diagnosed as having a benign thyroid adenoma.
The difference in the carcinoma rate between our study (~11%) and previous studies (~2%) is considered to be attributable to the timing of sample collection because there is no methodological difference between our pathological examination and previous ones - the sample collections (i.e., removal of thyroid gland by thyroidectomy) were carried out almost immediately after diagnosis and preoperative preparation for anaesthesia in previous studies [11,12]; on the other hand, our sampling was done after a certain period of medication. We could not gather enough information about the medication period from cooperating veterinary hospitals (cf. medical treatment ranging from 4 months to 7 years, with an average of 15.8 months according to published referral records [25]). Nevertheless, it is rational to consider that the previous studies have shown the tumor features at the initial stage of hyperthyroidism (i.e., the time of diagnosis) [11,12], and our results have shown those at the post-treatment stage (i.e., after a certain period of medication, at least a few months). Accordingly, the combination of previous studies [11,12] with our results (Figure 2) leads to speculation that the carcinoma rate increases from ~2% to ~11% of cases during medication.
A cross-section study based on 2,096 hyperthyroid cats has hypothesized that the prevalence of “suspected” thyroid carcinoma increases with increasing duration of medication [26]. This hypothesis is consistent with the above-mentioned speculation, so the following theory is built to interpret an obvious increase in the carcinoma rate (Figure 4): (i) anti-thyroid medication such as methimazole does not decrease tumor size [16,22], (ii) adenomatous tissues continue to grow over time despite medical therapy, and (iii) this growth predisposes the initiation of a carcinomatous process. The above-mentioned steps are illustrated in figure 4 to facilitate understanding of the proposed theory. It is broadly accepted that the adenoma-carcinoma sequence represents the process by which most colorectal cancers arise in humans (reviewed in [27,28]). A simplified version of this sequence is basically the conversion of normal colonic mucosa → (i) benign adenoma → (ii) advanced adenoma → (iii) ultimately progressing to carcinoma (reviewed in [27]). Thus, the feline sequence in thyroid carcinoma development seems to be similar to the human adenoma-carcinoma sequence in colorectal cancers (Figure 4).
There is a difference in terms of affected area between feline thyroid tumors (pharynx) and human colorectal cancers (colon), so doubt remains as to whether the adenoma-carcinoma sequence (i.e., the known mechanism of human colorectal cancer) occurs in thyroid tumors. The adenoma-carcinoma sequence is an enigmatic and debatable issue in thyroid tumors (reviewed in [29]). There are indirect evidences such as mixed simultaneous tumors, hostage theory and collision hypothesis to justify this sequence. Benign adenomas tend to have a higher prevalence of RAS gene mutations (a biomarker for the classical type of thyroid cancer), and papillary thyroid cancer tends to have a higher prevalence of BRAF gene mutations (a biomarker for the aggressive type of thyroid cancer), respectively [30]. A genetic study in human cases shows that similar N-RAS (a RAS gene family member) and BRAF mutations are prevalent in both benign and malignant thyroid nodules, so it is suggested that there is a possibility of adenoma-carcinoma sequence in thyroid tumors [31].
There seems to be a difference in the sequence timing between cats and humans. It takes between 10 and 15 years (a long term) for an adenoma to develop into a carcinoma in human colon cancers [28], whereas the growth rate of a feline tumor can vary and malignant tumors are often characterized by fast growth. A malignancy analysis of feline neoplasms has reported that malignant tumors tend to occur 8 months after benign ones at a mean age of 9.8 years in Portuguese cats [32]. Based on our findings, the average duration of medical therapy [25] and the onset timing of malignancy [32], it can be inferred that adenomatous thyroid tissues (benign tumors) transform into carcinomatous ones (malignant tumors) through a multistep mutational pathway similar to the human adenoma-carcinoma sequence in ~10% of hyperthyroid cats that are medically controlled, presumably in one to two years after the diagnosis time.
Thyroid adenomas are mainly classified into (i) an active (functional) type that produces excessive thyroid hormones and (ii) an inactive (non-functional) type that does not produce thyroid hormones [33]. Most thyroid adenomas are active in cats [11,12], but inactive in humans, so they do not often cause any symptoms [33]. With all that said, the diagnosis rate of low-risk thyroid cancers has been increasing in humans since the early 1980s (e.g., an increase rate of ~3% per year in the US [34,35]), and this increasing tendency of thyroid cancer in humans cannot be explained only by over-diagnosis and detection technology [36]. Cats are defined as sentinel species that can indicate health threats and potential risks to humans [37]; therefore, it remains for a future task to carefully assess whether an increasing rate of hyperthyroidism in cats since the late 1970s [11,12] is somehow related to the increasing rate of thyroid cancers in humans since the early 1980s [34,35].
A wide range of side effects has been reported in the use of anti-thyroid drugs (reviewed in [11,23]). Our observation of the hyperthyroid cat with ID number BP20-1438 is consistent with this report, so the importance of dose adjustments should be noted in pharmacological management of hyperthyroid cats. Furthermore, our findings suggest that thyroid nodules require careful follow-up for exclusion of malignancy in the presence of feline hyperthyroidism. As stated in the introduction, nowadays the annually increasing incidence of malignant tumors is of great concern in veterinary medicine for companion animals. This malignancy trend implies that a multistep mutational pathway like the human adenoma-carcinoma sequence may be becoming increasingly common in veterinary medicine without our realizing it.
Even if an increasing rate of hyperthyroidism in cats since the late 1970s is related to the increasing rate of thyroid cancers in humans since the early 1980s, it will be difficult to maintain awareness of oncogenic risk because human thyroid adenoma is often inactive and asymptomatic in the face of its malignant potential [33]. The above chronological order is reminiscent of Minamata disease, which is a typical example of peculiar health damage in Japan. The outbreak of the disease in humans was preceded by abnormal behaviors (drooling, spinning in circles, etc.) in local cats in the 1950s [38]. This disease was coined “Dancing Cat Syndrome” in its early days; however, the syndrome was a precursor to severe neurological disorders that subsequently developed in a large number (~100 thousand cases) of human residents of Minamata Bay [39]. Considering that cats are categorized as sentinel species, the prevalence of feline hyperthyroidism potentially associated with the adenoma-carcinoma sequence may be a sign of what will next emerge in human beings on a global scale.
We thank 206 cats, their owners and the 65 cooperating veterinary hospitals for supplying tissue samples, Yu Animal Hospital for clinical records, Dr. N. Yoshida of Kyoto Prefectural University of Medicine for helpful suggestions, and Ms. C. Lentfer for English review. Special thanks are given to a Portuguese cat Mimi for providing us with response data for assessing medication effects.
RK developed the conceptualization and aided in interpreting the results. YK performed the pathology examination and the data processing, and RPRC reviewed and edited the manuscript from the veterinary viewpoint. All authors provided critical feedback.
No funding was received for conducting this research.
The datasets are available from the corresponding author upon proper request.
Sample collections were approved by all the pet owners and the cooperative veterinary hospitals.
The authors declare no competing interests.
SignUp to our
Content alerts.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Are you the author of a recent Preprint? We invite you to submit your manuscript for peer-reviewed publication in our open access journal.
Benefit from fast review, global visibility, and exclusive APC discounts.